The Greatest Mattress Pillows

Our high picks apart, testers’ responses to pillows have been everywhere, so learn this part with your individual preferences in thoughts. An element that knocked some pillows out of the operating for us is likely to be simply what you’re keen on in a pillow. We’ve famous which pillows side-, back-, and stomach-sleepers discovered snug.


L.L.Bean 700-Fill-Power Sateen White Goose Down Pillow (firm)
Good for: stomach-sleepers
We examined all three densities of L.L.Bean’s 700-Fill-Energy pillow, however solely the agency density made it into our sleep exams. It scored very effectively with stomach-sleepers who like down, with one telling us, “It actually conformed to my sleeping positions very well, while still keeping its form. It felt very, very supportive.” It didn’t rating as effectively with side-, back-, or combo-sleepers. We’ve additionally seen these pillows go out and in of inventory.

Parachute Down Pillow (soft)
Good for: stomach-sleepers
Parachute’s softest pillow was our earlier high choose for stomach-sleepers, and we nonetheless assume it’s the most effective pillow should you’re a stomach-sleeper and also you need only a contact of help in your head. One stomach-sleeper informed us, “It stays even and the material doesn’t shift around over time. To me, it’s always soft and comfortable.” Our abdomen/aspect combo-sleeper couldn’t make it by an evening with this Parachute, although, as a result of it was so skinny.

Parachute Down Pillow (firm)
Good for: stomach- and back-sleepers
The agency model of the Parachute Down Pillow was once our improve choose, and we nonetheless assume it’s a fantastic choose for down lovers. A few testers mentioned that it didn’t keep lofty all through the night time, however others cherished the way it cradled their head.

Brooklinen Down Pillow (plush)
Good for: stomach-sleepers
Abdomen-sleepers preferring a delicate, squishy pillow cherished this down pillow, however those that wanted extra help didn’t. One stomach-sleeper reported that it made her really feel “like my head was floating weightless on a freakin’ cloud from heaven.”

Cuddledown 700 Fill Power European White Goose Down Sateen Pillow (medium)
Good for: stomach- and back-sleepers
A few of our back-sleepers actually appreciated Cuddledown’s medium-fill pillow, whereas others discovered it snug however not exceptional. One stomach-sleeper gave it an ideal rating and informed us, “It’s soft with enough cushion for my neck. It didn’t feel overly-firm, and it felt supportive for a variety of sleeping positions. It’s a really good multi-use pillow.” Nonetheless, it’s expensive, and it didn’t outperform different pillows we examined for back- and stomach-sleepers.

Feathered Friends Down Pillow – 700 Fill (medium and firm)
Good for: back- and side-sleepers
Again- and side-sleepers appreciated the luxurious high quality of the Feathered Buddies agency and medium 700-fill pillows. However some wished extra help, whereas others wished much less from each the medium and agency variations. When you’re involved concerning the ethics of down, Feathered Buddies is an effective selection as a result of its merchandise are RDS licensed.

Crane & Canopy Back Sleeper Goose Down Pillow
Good for: back-sleepers
Testers cherished the fluffiness of Crane & Cover’s Again Sleeper however had issues with its degree of help—some discovered it too agency, whereas others mentioned their head “bottomed out” in the course of the night time. For individuals who desire a medium-loft down pillow, this one is price a strive.

Brooklinen Down Pillow (firm)
Good for: side-sleepers
This pillow is created from a mixture of feathers and down, which makes it rather less lofty than all-down variations. Aspect-sleepers didn’t discover it as snug as different down pillows we tried.

Brooklinen Down Pillow (mid-plush)
Good for: back-sleepers
Again-sleepers discovered that the mid-plush model (additionally manufactured from feathers and down) didn’t maintain its loft in addition to the competitors, and mentioned it wasn’t as snug as they anticipated from down.

Lands’ End Elite Goose Down Pillow (soft)
Good for: stomach-sleepers
Considered one of our stomach-sleepers appreciated this pillow however famous that the corporate’s decision to pull an interview with Gloria Steinem from its catalogue made her bitter on the model, which raises an auxiliary level: If the branding of a pillow resonates with you—or doesn’t—which will have an effect on how a lot you prefer it.

Down various

Sleep Number PlushComfort Pillow Classic
Good for: all sleep positions
We choose the adjustability of the PlushComfort Final, however the PlushComfort Traditional was one of many comfier down-alternative pillows in our 2019 testing. Aspect-sleepers discovered it extra supportive than the Snowe Down Various pillows and far softer than the Brooklinen Down Various. When you like a medium-density pillow—in any sleep place—that is one to think about.

Parachute Down Alternative Side Sleeper Pillow
Good for: back-sleepers
It might sound counterintuitive, however Parachute’s side-sleeper pillow was fairly snug for our back-sleepers. One tester who prefers a lower-loft pillow famous that it felt somewhat too squishy by the top of the night time, nevertheless it brought about no discomfort. It’s effectively made, and the gussets assist preserve the delicate fill evenly distributed inside the duvet. When you can’t discover the Sleep Quantity PlushComfort Final, this pillow would possibly give you the results you want.

Cuddledown 450 Thread Count Sateen Synthetic Fill Pillow (overfilled)
Good for: side-sleepers
When you’re a side-sleeper and also you don’t like foam pillows however want particularly agency help, that is the pillow to strive. In our 2018 sleep panel exams, we examined solely the medium-density model of this Cuddledown pillow, however we’ve since gone again and examined each the overfilled and delicate densities with a smaller check group. We expect the overfilled model is a superb selection for side-sleepers—it was firmer and extra supportive than the agency Snowe Down Various and loftier than the Sleep Quantity PlushComfort Traditional. Considered one of our side-sleepers, who prefers further top and really agency help, used to stack two down-alternative pillows to get sufficient top however was snug utilizing this pillow by itself.

Cuddledown 450 Thread Count Sateen Synthetic Fill Pillow (soft)
Good for: stomach-sleepers
When you’re a stomach-sleeper and also you don’t need loads of loft and don’t like down, and the Sleep Quantity PlushComfort Final is unavailable, we advocate this Cuddledown pillow within the delicate density. It doesn’t supply as a lot help because the PlushComfort, however our stomach-sleeper nonetheless discovered it snug, preferring it to the soft-density Parachute Down Pillow. The outer shell is thicker, and the material is smoother, than that of the Parachute, and though our tester didn’t love that really feel, as soon as the pillow was inside a pillowcase it wasn’t noticeable.

Leesa Hybrid Pillow
Good for: back-sleepers
A few of our back-sleepers appreciated this pillow. One aspect of the pillow is tufted for further loft, whereas the opposite is flat and clean. It additionally has a smaller, detachable pillow inside with a cooling gel insert surrounded by artificial fill. “I appreciate being able to take out the extra small pillow inside, probably the size of an airplane pillow, because I like my pillows extra thin,” one tester informed us. After 5 months, she’s nonetheless utilizing this pillow frequently and loves it. One other famous, “This pillow had just the right amount of firmness for making sleeping on my side or back comfortable. It seemed to adapt well to my different neck and head positions. It’s also just fun to squish.” Our third back-sleeping tester discovered that it was too stuffed and had some neck ache within the night time.

Crane & Canopy Down Alternative Sham Pillow
Good for: all sleep positions
One stomach-sleeping tester who tends to choose pillows with ample loft mentioned that this was the primary typical (that means not memory-foam or buckwheat) pillow she cherished sufficient to purchase herself. Different testers reported that it was supportive however dense, and that it felt “deflated and hard” by the morning.

MyPillow Premium (green, white, and yellow)
Good for: all sleep positions
The MyPillow Premium’s vary of choices make it look like the reply to the customization downside—as an alternative of getting you purchase a pillow by agency, medium, or delicate designations, and even by your sleeping place, MyPillow asks you a handful of questions and determines which kind of pillow is the most effective match, assigning colours as an alternative of descriptive names. This method labored magic for one back-sleeper on our panel, who referred to as the inexperienced MyPillow among the finest pillows he’d ever slept on; one side-sleeper additionally cherished its lofty help. However testers discovered the yellow and white variations lumpy, flat, and unsupportive, even when their MyPillow sleeping profiles indicated that they’d be finest off with these sorts.

Riley Down Alternative Pillow (firm)
Good for: stomach-sleepers
Riley’s firm-density pillow was snug for a number of nights, however then it started to harm one tester’s ear. It’s a nice, well-stuffed pillow should you change positions or like extra top, nevertheless it is likely to be too stiff for some, and it wasn’t considerably higher than different pillows we examined.

Parachute Down Alternative Pillow (firm)
Good for: side-sleepers
Our 2017 panel of side-sleepers appreciated Parachute’s agency down-alternative pillow however no more than the others we examined.

Parachute Down Alternative Pillow (soft)
Good for: stomach-sleepers
In our exams, stomach-sleepers who appreciated a delicate pillow with little help appreciated this pillow, however those that wished extra substance discovered it merely flat.

The Original Casper Pillow
Good for: all sleep positions
One tester cherished this pillow, whereas all people else thought it was simply nice. It wasn’t as moldable or supportive as our side- and back-sleepers wished. Abdomen-sleepers who most well-liked a flatter pillow discovered the Casper too thick, although they famous that it was helpful for stomach-sleepers who shift to their aspect all through the night time.

Cuddledown 450 Thread Count Sateen Synthetic Fill Pillow (medium)
Good for: stomach- and side-sleepers
This pillow’s scores have been all around the map. One stomach-sleeper informed us it was one of many higher synthetic-fill pillows, whereas one other thought it was too puffy and agency. One side-sleeper mentioned it sank an excessive amount of, whereas one other who usually makes use of two pillows famous, “I started with two pillows and actually switched in the night. It was pretty great on its own.”

Shredded foam

Sleep Number ComfortFit Pillow Classic
Good for: all sleep positions
In two years of testing, side-sleepers have appreciated this pillow quite a bit, and it ranked in the midst of the pack for back- and stomach-sleepers. However nobody appreciated it higher than the Nest Bedding Simple Breather or the Xtreme Comforts.

The Saatva Pillow
Good for: side-sleepers
When you just like the squishy really feel of down various however want firmer, loftier help, you would possibly just like the shredded-latex and down-alternative Saatva Pillow. It was the general favourite in 2019 testing for information author Jackie Reeve, a side-sleeper who likes a tall, agency pillow and cherished the softly supportive Saatva, which felt cloudlike. A shredded Talalay latex core is surrounded by down-alternative fill, and you may take away the core—though one in every of our sleep-testers tried this and located that the pillow wasn’t supportive in any respect. Most of our testers didn’t like the feel, which was delicate however not as squishy as a plain down-alternative pillow.

Langria Luxury Bamboo Shredded Memory Foam Pillow
Good for: back-sleepers
The Langria is the least-expensive shredded-foam pillow we’ve examined. It was snug for such an inexpensive pillow, nevertheless it didn’t rating as excessive in our exams because the Simple Breather, the Sleep Quantity ComfortFit Final, and the Xtreme Comforts pillow.

Xtreme Comforts Slim Sleeper Shredded Memory Foam Pillow
Good for: stomach-sleepers
This can be a model of the Xtreme Comforts we like as a finances choose, simply with much less fill. We discovered that individuals who choose a flattish pillow appreciated down choices extra, and that individuals who wished a pillow with extra help wanted extra loft.

Nest Bedding Easy Breather Natural Pillow
Good for: back- and side-sleepers
The Pure model of Nest Bedding’s Easy Breather has an organic-cotton cowl and is made with shredded latex foam as an alternative of reminiscence foam. It smelled a bit when it arrived, however that odor light after a number of days. It didn’t really feel as snug as the unique Simple Breather throughout our first spherical of testing, so we didn’t see a cause to sleep-test each.

One-piece reminiscence foam

Weekender Gel Memory Foam Pillow
Good for: side-sleepers
The finances choose in our guide to memory-foam pillows was one of many highest-rated memory-foam pillows we examined in 2019. It didn’t trigger overheating like another solid-foam pillows we tried, and its low value makes it a fantastic selection if you wish to strive a solid-foam pillow however aren’t certain you’ll prefer it. This pillow shouldn’t be as tall as most memory-foam pillows we’ve thought-about, so should you choose a medium loft, it would give you the results you want.

Tempur-Pedic Tempur-Adapt Pro + Cooling Pillow (mid-density)
Good for: back- and side-sleepers
The improve choose in our memory-foam pillows guide is tall, cool, and really effectively made. It’s the highest-quality solid-foam pillow we tried in 2019, and it molds to the form of your head and neck with out sinking too low. It’s a wonderful selection should you like very agency help, nevertheless it’s not adjustable, which makes it much less versatile than shredded-foam pillows.

Ecosa Pillow
Good for: side- and back-sleepers
The Ecosa is the one contoured pillow we advocate in our memory-foam pillows guide, and it’s our favourite pillow to assist with neck and head ache. Our testers reached for this pillow when coping with migraines, sinus complications, and persistent neck ache. The Ecosa presents agency help that’s nonetheless delicate, so your neck can curve over the contoured form and nonetheless really feel cushioned.

Tuft & Needle Original Foam Pillow
Good for: stomach-sleepers
The Tuft & Needle could possibly be a superb wager for stomach-sleepers who like one-piece memory-foam pillows—nevertheless it reminded us why we didn’t check extra one-piece reminiscence foam pillows. Testers discovered it too low for comfortably sleeping on their again or aspect, and too stiff to mould to their head.

Malouf Z Zoned Gel ActiveDough Pillow, Malouf Z Convolution Pillow, and Leesa Pillow
We tried these pillows in our first spherical of 2018 exams however didn’t find yourself sleeping on them. They endure from the identical issues as the remainder of the solid-foam pillows we’ve tried: They’re tougher, flatter, and fewer moldable, so that they attraction solely to a couple particular folks.

About the Author

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *